Air Leakage Testing: How to Set an Acceptable Leak Rate
A useful air leakage testing specification needs more than a statement such as “no leaks”. Every practical test has a measurement limit, and the acceptable leakage for a product should be linked to what the product must do in service.
The objective is to define a leak rate that protects function and safety while remaining measurable and repeatable in production. A tighter number is not automatically a better number if it adds test time and false rejects without improving real-world performance.
Start with the consequence of leakage
Work backwards from what happens if the product leaks. The concern might be loss of pressure, ingress of moisture, loss of a working fluid, contamination or failure to maintain a sealed environment.
That consequence should then be linked to service life, maintenance interval and normal operating conditions. A product expected to maintain performance for many years may need a different limit from a component that is inspected or serviced frequently.
Separate the product requirement from instrument sensitivity
The acceptable leak rate describes what the product is allowed to do. Instrument sensitivity describes what the test system can reliably measure. These are related, but they are not the same thing.
Leak testing equipment should be selected after the functional requirement is understood. Choosing an instrument first and then using its smallest detectable value as the product specification can create a limit that has no relationship to service performance.
Define the test conditions clearly
An air leakage testing result is only meaningful when the test conditions are stated. The specification should define the pressure, test medium, temperature conditions where relevant, units and the point at which the part passes or fails.
If the product uses a liquid or a different gas in service, the production air test should be correlated with the real functional requirement rather than relying on a simple assumed conversion. Reference parts or known leak conditions can help demonstrate that the production test is measuring something that matters.
Set a production threshold with measurement margin
The reject threshold should account for normal measurement variation. A production system should not sit exactly on the theoretical maximum with no allowance for fixture repeatability, instrument variation or environmental effects.
Measurement-system studies such as gauge repeatability and reproducibility can help establish how much confidence there is around the result. Parts around the proposed threshold should then be tested to confirm that passing and failing conditions can be distinguished reliably.
Avoid making the leak rate unnecessarily tight
As the allowable change becomes smaller, the test generally becomes more sensitive to stabilisation, fixture quality and environmental noise. This can lengthen the test cycle and increase false rejects.
With air decay leak testing, for example, warm parts or changing temperatures can affect the measured pressure. A specification that is tighter than the functional requirement may therefore make production harder without improving the product.
Validate before releasing the specification
Before a limit is used in production, test representative good and bad parts around the proposed threshold. Confirm that the selected method, fixture and cycle can repeat the result and that the test correlates with the product’s actual performance requirement.
This validation step is important whether the chosen leak testing equipment uses pressure decay, mass flow or tracer gas. The specification, method and process conditions need to work together. The production team should also document the units, pressure, medium and acceptance threshold so future engineering changes do not leave the same numeric limit being used under different test conditions. For air leakage testing, consistency is essential if results are to remain comparable over time.
Need help defining an acceptable leak rate?
TQC can support air leakage testing from the initial requirement through to method selection, fixture design and production equipment. Explore our leak testing equipment and services and contact the engineering team to discuss an application where the leak limit is unclear or needs reviewing.